Department of English                               Gymnasium Steglitz Berlin

<back

>Contact

Various Essays on E.M. Forsterīs "The Machine Stops"


 
Escalation of technology could isolate people

Technological progress produces fear and respect

Can we control technical progress in the future?

Forsterīs story is a warning to future generations

Forster challenges the spirit of his age

 

Read E.M. Forsterīs story here


Escalation of technology could isolate people

E.M.Forster
(1879 - 1970)

The science-fiction story "The Machine Stops" was written by E.M. Forster in 1909. It begins with a conversation between a mother named Vashti and her unhappy son Kuno some time in the distant future. People no longer live on the surface of the earth but in air-ships.
Vashti lives in a single room which consists entirely of technology and machinery. She spends all her time in an electronic arm-chair and is grossly overweight. The ventilation, lighting and also the music in the room are electrically controlled. When Kuno calls her, he tries to explain to her his dissatisfaction with life as it is. He says he would like to see and to hear her in real life and not just through a technical communication machine. Kuno asks her to pay him a visit. But unfortunately Vashti does not agree with his idea. She is of the opinion that it is sufficient to see one another through the phone machine. Besides she has no time for visiting.
When they cannot agree Kunoīs image in the machine plate fades and Vashti is alone again.

The authorīs main theme is a vision of the earth in the distant future, when computer development has increased dramatically and everything in life is controlled by technology. He exploits his idea to illustrate that advanced developments in technology will not only destroy the communication between people but also the earth itself. People will not have personal contact with family members and friends if technology develops as far as it does in the story.
This is the warning the author is trying to give the reader. He shows it very clearly in the story by the behaviour of the mother. She is absolutely not interested in seeing her son, because she thinks they both have everything they need and do not have to see one another personally.
In my opinion it is very good that E.M. Forster makes this important theme "development of technology and computers" the main point of his story. I think everyone ought to think and to be worried about the future of technology. The results of the development could become really dangerous for the human race. Of course, we need things like phones, television, electricity, cars and aeroplanes. What would we do without them? We could not travel, communicate with friends in other countries and we also could not be informed about the news. However, if we allow these modern conveniences to develop as in Forsterīs story, everybody would only sit in front of the computer or communication devices and not socialize with one another.
So I hope technology does not develop and escalate as far as in Forsterīs story. I think that communication between people is much more important than the very latest technology. (M.N., 11b, March 2005)

 

Technological progress produces fear and respect

machinestops.jpg (8230 Byte)The science-fiction story "The Machine stops" by E.M. Forster was written in 1909. In the story the author potrays a world thousand of years in the future where people live in the interior of the earth.
At the beginning of the story Kuno calls his mother and tells her that he wants to see her face to face and not through the plate which is a part of the usual communication at that time. His mother is irritated and does not understand him, because she does not see any necessity for it. When Kuno tells her that he wants to visit the surface of the earth she is totally shocked and tries to dissuade him from the idea. The mother and Kuno get into a dispute about the Machines. Because of the motherīs lack of understanding Kuno finishes the conversation by terminating the connection. For a short moment the mother feels lonley, but then she recovers and returns into her life conditioned by technology.
The main characters of the story are Vashti, the mother, and her son Kuno. The mother illustrates the kind of people living in complete agreement with the technological world and whose life is totally influenced by it. For this reason she represents the supporters of the technological revolution. Technology has such a big status in her life that even the relation to her son does not mean very much to her.
In contrast to the mother her son Kuno illustrates the critic of technology and a kind of revolt against a social life made possible only by technological means.

In my opinion the author used the two characters to make clear the problematic situation of the emergence of the means of communication in the 20th century. In this way he illustrates the fascination which is produced by the technological progress on the one hand, on the other hand he describes the fear of people and their respect for technology. E.M. Forster portrays this situation by moving people’s lives into the interior of the earth. The reason of it is the destruction of the surface of the earth, which makes life impossible otherwise.
Furthermore the author mentions in his short story another consequence of the technological progress. The son wants a personal contact to his mother, but Vashti is satisfied with her artificial contacts. I suppose that the author wants to express that the importance of interpersonal relations is threatened by the emergence of the technical means of communication.
In my opinion the description of the future is a bit exaggerated. The idea of the author that thousands of years in the future when life on earth will be impossible people will live under the surface of the earth, sounds too unrealistic to me. The description of the technological situation in the future is also a bit excessive, but in a certain way Forster has imagined the future of communication as it is now. Nowadays everyone is used to many different means of communication and probably life would almost be inconceivable without them.  (J.S., 11b, March 2005)

 

Can we control technical progress in the future?

The opening of the science-fiction short story "The Machine Stops" by E.M Foster, which takes place in the remote future, is about a telephone conversation between a mother and her son concerning issues of the technical revolution.
At the beginning we are told that the mother named Vashti lives isolated in her room under the earth. She does not go outside and lives alone, which is also a reason for her "
being white as a fungus" and swaddled appearance. When her son, who lives on the other side of the earth, asks her to visit him, she does not want to come. She talks to him through a machine, a plate, in which they can see the faces of each other. The son wants to see his mother personally, but she dislikes to go outside, to fly with an air-ship and to see the surface of the earth. Because she does not have any good arguments not to come, the son gives up trying to convince his mother. He isolates himself and the mother feels sad about it, but only a moment. She continues to live her life in the flat and assumes to have everything she needs.

I think E.M Foster intends to warn us about the technical developments and to show what kind of problems such progress could bring along. The technical revolution makes us live alone and isolated. You have buttons to communicate with your friends and you can see them through a machine. You need not go outside to see somebody or to do something, everything is in your flat. There even is a button to call for food for example, you need not go into a supermarket.
Apart from peopleīs psychological constitution, their health cannot be very good. They are isolated from the natural environment. They never see the sun and do not move, even in their flats they move around without leaving the chair. Remember Vashti, whom the author describes "as white as fungus and as very swaddled".

In my opinion, on the one hand Forster’s idea of the future is a little unrealistic. I do not think that anbody could live without human contact and that this will be normal in the future. In addition I do not think that in the future a mother does not want personal contact to her son. If noone could leave his flat, mankind would die out. You also have to work to be able to live in this kind of flat. Somebody must produce all these machines and for example the food cannot come "out of the air". But on the other hand nobody knows how the future will be like, and maybe thousand years ago the people could not imagine the world as it is today; for example the fact that you can "beam" a message with a phone from one side of the earth to the other. Therefore the story could also be realistic.
I have come to the conclusion that on the one hand the extract of the short story "The Machine Stops" is full of fantasy, but on the other hand gives "food for thought" about the control of the technical development. We should not forget that we must keep the control over the machines and that they should not take control over us.  (L.G., 11b, March 2005)

 

Forsterīs story is a warning to future generations

The extract of the short story "The Machine Stops" written by the famous science-fiction author E. M. Forster in 1909 portrays a future world in which the characters live under the surface of the earth in a system called "The Machine", which makes this sort of life possible.
One of the two main characters is Vashti, a mother who lives alone in her underground lodging. In this extract she talks to her son Kuno, who lives on the other side of the world, via the machine. Kuno wants her to pay him a visit for a conversation, but Vashti refuses. For her it seems unnecessary to visit him when they can easily talk by using the machine. When Kuno tells her that he wants to visit the uninhabited surface of the earth and to break out of his life in the machine, an action that would risk his life, they have an argument about the importance of the machine. Kuno does not accept his mother’s positive opinion about the machine and terminates the conversation.

"The Machine stops" is a story about a future world such as ours may become, if we continue to rely more and more on machinery. Forster portrays an entirely indoor society. The people in the story live in isolation in a machine which controls all aspects of their daily lives. The machine is much more important to the inhabitants of this future world than our computers and other tools are to us today. It guarantees the life of the inhabitants of that world by providing fresh air, water and food. The importance of the machine is due to this dependence.
Whatever the benefits of the machine, as one can see from the conversation between Vashti and her son, it also affects their lives in a very negative way. Real face-to-face conversation no longer takes place, even between mother and son. The people of that world only place value on man-made things.

But why does everybody live below the surface of our earth? The answer seems simple. The environment was somehow poisoned and made uninhabitable, and as a result the whole human population moved underground to seek safety. This idea of Forster is not absurd at all in our time of increasing damage to the environment and risk of nuclear war. In my opinion Forsterīs story is a warning to his and future generations not to lose control over their inventions or to overestimate their importance. He creates a deterrent image in his reader’s minds of how the world could become if we live without any consideration of natural behaviour. I hope this warning will be taken seriously because I believe that communication is one of the most important aspects of life, and it should never be replaced by technical inventions like machines.  (L.K., 11b, March 2005)

 

Forster challenges the spirit of his age

The short story "The Machine Stops" by E.M. Forster written in 1909 is about the future of technology and how mankind will be contingent on one machine that controls everything. Because the earth is not habitable anymore, the people live in some kind of machine. The main character of the story is a boy called Kuno, who some day calls his mother Vashti to tell her that he wants to see her, but not through the machine anymore, rather meet her face to face. Vashti who is totally integrated in the technical life is shocked by her son saying something against "The Machine" and tries to argue him out of thinking something like that. Later on he even tells her that he intends visiting the surface of the earth to see the world like people did thousands of years ago. Vashti does not understand how somebody could like to leave the comfortable Machine and walk over the nasty ground of the earth. At the end of the extract the author explains the technical contraptions which are built in the room of Vashti to make life comfortable and allow the inhabitant to do everything without moving out of the room.

The story is called "The Machine Stops" and the title is associated with Kunoīs volition to challenge the technical side of life in his age and try out the life without the influence of "The Machine". In contrast Vashti is totally dependent on this system and she does not understand her sonīs choice. In her opinion "it is contrary to the spirit of the age".
In my opinion it becomes apparent that not the familial relation of the two main characters but rather their two ideas of perception of a mechanically controlled life come to the fore. Whereas the younger generation, personified by Kuno, wants to challenge the sytem, try something new and longs for a shifting, the older generation, personified by Vashti, resists to every kind of changing and wants to cleave to the system. On account of this the generational conflict is an important point of the story and this kind of conflict is conferrable to every age.

The text is a narration, and the author wrote this story in short sentences. He uses short accounts to convey a clear impression of the ambience of the machines. With this story E.M. Forster tries to show how negative it could end if the technical revolution goes too far. Although the story was written in 1909, it shows the difficulty of this topic.  (T.P., 11b, March 2005)

 

 

 

Other websites of our Department of English

If you are doing an interesting project let us know

 

www.gymnasiumsteglitz.de
Gymnasium Steglitz, 12169 Berlin, Heesestraße 15
Tel.: 030/9395-1937, Fax: 030/9395-1939

All rights reserved! Đ 2000-2005